Are Your ‘Unique Benefits’ Neither?
Companies tout customer service as a differentiator, but that’s not
enough to impress decision makers.
by Tim Riesterer
HA 2009 SURVEY of 9,000 decision makers in B2B companies found that 86% of
the “unique benefits” touted by vendors were not perceived as unique or
having enough impact to create preference. Unwittingly, it appears,
companies are creating value parity-positions, not value propositions.
Is it any wonder you are having a hard time getting customers to start sales
cycles with you? The survey results would also explain the rising number of
“no decisions” at the end of opportunities.
This article offers the following three rules for creating preference vs.
parity in your value propositions.
1. Put it in context. The Marketing Leadership Council of
the Corporate Executive Board, authors of the survey, say the biggest
failure point in most company value propositions is “proximity.” That is,
because of marketers’ proximity to their own company and products, they
overestimate the uniqueness and relevance of the benefits they promote. And
one of the biggest problems with proximity is that it causes marketers to
mistake customer touch points for value propositions.
Companies like to tout such things as customer service as a differentiator.
But research has found that decision makers see those touch points as
marginal or poor drivers of preference. What really gets customers excited
is hearing about clear, unique benefits that address their business needs.
Strategic agenda items such as “streamline my supply chain” or “help me get
more out of my current capital investments” are what people will pay you
for, because those items are relevant to their responsibilities and how
their organizations hold them accountable.
Needs-based benefits that show customers how to do something better tomorrow
than they do today were proven to be four times more powerful predictors of
preference vs. touch points, according to the CEB research.
Also, remember that you get delegated to whoever you talk like. Make sure
that the needs you address are presented in the context of the person who
can make a purchase decision. The tendency is to drift toward the user of
your products or services; typically, that person isn’t the key decision
maker.
Preference vs. Parity Rule 1: No context, no value proposition.
2. Show it in contrast. Do your value propositions create
contrast for customers? Do they see themselves in enough pain with their
current situation to replace, upgrade or otherwise change the status quo?
And, more important, do you clearly align what you do and show the relevant
gain, with regard to that pain?
If your prospects hear your message or listen to your story and they can’t
see themselves eliminating challenges and positively changing their
strategic agenda in a significant way, you don’t have a value proposition.
Value lies in the contrast between the pain and the gain.
Brain research proves that humans make decisions that are more adaptive than
rational. They need to see a change in their environment that makes the
status quo no longer acceptable. They need to see that change is coming now,
and that your solution is critical to their survival.
In fact, you need to inject emotion into your messaging. Even in B2B, you
have to get decision makers emotionally invested in the decision. They will
justify with facts, but they will buy based on how your solution will
influence their success or failure in their jobs.
It’s only by creating a dramatic contrast between how bad things are today
and how good things will be after they partner with you that you can get
prospects to create an opportunity and champion a decision in their
organization.
Preference vs. Parity Rule 2: No contrast, no value proposition.
3. Prove it with corroboration. The third rule pertains to
proof points. Most marketers think of proof points as quantifiable
validation of the value you provide. That’s true, but it’s only partially
true. When you are trying to get prospects to care enough to consider a
change and choose you, proof points must corroborate your solution on two
levels.
First, you need proof points that will corroborate or turn up the heat on
the problem. “Amping up the pain” is what I like to call it. For example, at
the beginning of this article I told you that 86% of unique benefits that
companies cite don’t create preference. I bet it got you thinking about your
own benefits statements and value propositions. It hooked you into the story
and got you to care about a potential solution.
Second, you need proof points that will corroborate your claims to be able
to solve the problem in a meaningful way that eliminates the pain and brings
measurable gain around the strategic item you are addressing. One example of
that in this article was the research finding that needs-based benefits are
four times more powerful than touch-point-based benefits.
Do you have documented results that validate what doing something different
tomorrow will mean to your customers — in terms they care about?
Preference vs. Parity Rule 3: No corroboration, no value proposition.
Use those three rules when creating your value propositions and you will
discover the difference between preference and parity.
Tim Riesterer is chief marketing officer and SVP of
Strategic Consulting for Corporate Visions ( www.corporatevisions.com).
He is also the co-author of Customer Message Management: Increasing
Marketing’s Impact on Selling.
Demand rising for ‘good enough’ products
The “Great Middle Market” shopper — not too cheap but not too expensive — is
a dying breed. The economic crisis has upset the gravy train that once was the
“Great Middle” tier, comprised of consumers larded with credit and competing to
stay one up on the Joneses.
The new winners are companies such as Apple and Hermes that can still convince
consumers to pay more for significantly better products, and on the other end,
companies such as Vizio and Ikea that sell “good enough” products at very low
prices.
The losers? Everyone else, such as GM and Sony, who once fattened their bottom
lines on sales to the Great Middle, or what economics writer James Surowiecki
characterizes as “making money by selling moderately good products that are
moderately expensive.” That’s not a winning formula today. Midrange products are
neither exceptional enough to justify premium prices nor cheap enough to win
over value-conscious consumers.
Today, the information revolution allows consumers to research products in
depth, making them comfortable with trading down. Furthermore, today’s cheaper
products are becoming higher quality.
Finally, in uncertain times, certainty sells, giving support to the high end.
Consumers are still investing in well-known brands that deliver consistent
quality and provide psychological comfort.
Source: Bnet.com, March 24, 2010
Is location marketing the next big opportunity?
It’s the ad served while you are reading the news on an e-reader that knows
you’re at home and three blocks from a Starbucks. It’s finding a restaurant in a
strange city on your iPhone, discovering that a store nearby stocks the TV
you’re looking for or that a certain grocery on the way home has the cut of meat
you need.
The potential of knowing when and where a consumer is — within privacy
constraints — is expected to open up the floodgates for location-based
marketing.
“What used to be called point-of-purchase is now called mobile advertising,”
said Kip Cassino, VP-Research at Borrell Associates. “Mobile can be an extension
of a retailer’s storefront.”
Borrell estimates mobile will dominate U.S. interactive marketing spending as
soon as 2014 with 70% share, based on the growing use of smartphones, Kindles,
iPads and portable gaming devices.
Companies such as Placecast set what’s called a “geo-fence” around retail
locations and, once you opt in, blast FYIs or offers texts when you’re within a
determined radius. In a four-month study with the American Eagle retail and
Sonic restaurant chains, Placecast reported 79% of participating consumers said
geo-fencing programs increased their likelihood to visit stores, and 65% made
purchases during the program.
Source: Advertising Age, March 22, 2010
Micropayments may finally be set to surge
Online and mobile commerce is about to get a shot in the arm. Online payment
service PayPal is opening the door to widespread use of credit and debit cards
for so-called micropayments — as small as half a buck and up to about $12.
Instead of charging separately for each transaction they handle, the company
plans to aggregate a merchandiser’s micropayments and levy a single fee for the
bundle.
Cheap processing of micropayments is hailed as the answer to many sellers’
prayers. Publishers, for example, will be able to sell articles online “by the
drink.” And lower fees should help industries already using micropayments such
as ring tone merchants and smartphone application marketplaces. Craftspeople and
entrepreneurs who sell low-value goods on e-marketplaces will also benefit.
“Microservices” may appear in which, say, a small fee paid by cell phone could
take a customer to the front of a long line.
The micropayment economy has been promised before, but experts say mobile
commerce and newfound trust in online transactions will make the difference.
Source: Kiplinger.com, April 7, 2010
Need speed? Slow down
Companies fearful of losing their competitive advantage spend a lot of time
and resources looking for ways to pick up the pace. However, new research
suggests they try slowing down instead.
Researchers at The Forum Corporation found that companies that chose to go, go,
go to try to gain an edge ended up with lower sales and operating profits than
those that paused at key moments to make sure they were on the right track.
What’s more, the firms that “slowed down to speed up” averaged 40% higher sales
and 52% higher operating profits over a three-year period.
But what does “slower” and “faster” really mean in business? Firms sometimes
confuse operational speed (moving quickly) with strategic speed (reducing the
time it takes to deliver value). Simply increasing the pace of production may
lead to quality problems, while fast-moving strategic initiatives may not
deliver value if time isn’t taken to identify and adjust the true value
proposition.
In the study, higher-performing companies with strategic speed made sure that
everyone was aligned in support of projects. They were more open to ideas and
innovation, and they allowed time to reflect and learn. By contrast, performance
suffered at firms that moved fast all the time, focused too much on maximizing
efficiency, stuck to tested methods and didn’t foster employee collaboration.
Source: Harvard Business Review, May 2010
Appealing unemployment claims can backfire
With unemployment taxes increasing, more small business owners may be
motivated to appeal claims for unemployment benefits filed by former employees
who quit or were fired for cause — but such appeals can sometimes backfire.
Employers may want to appeal unwarranted claims, experts say, but be aware that
the effort could inadvertently prompt a former employee to file discrimination,
harassment or other charges in retaliation.
Another possible outcome is that a business owner ends up owing back taxes to
the government because he or she fought to deny benefits to an independent
contractor who should have been classified as a regular employee.
Some cases do pay off: In 2009, employers filed 405,153 appeals to deny benefits
to former workers and 36% won, a figure that hasn’t changed too much in recent
years, according to the U.S. Department of Labor. The key is having good
documentation showing the previous employee doesn’t qualify for benefits.
Source: Wall Street Journal, April 6, 2010
- What’s the best way
to communicate with your
customers? Learning the
answer could hurt your marketing
efforts. That’s because
marketers will often only focus
on one best communication
method. But these days consumers
engage with a variety of online
communications and activities
and have different preferences
and tastes. For example, while
email may be your best method
right now, consider mixing
things up by using social
networking websites such as
LinkedIn, Facebook, Twitter,
YouTube and others. Your
customers don’t see these
channels as mutually exclusive.
Why should you?
Source: www.marketingprofs.com
- Spice up your
company newsletter and expand
your network by touting
the services of business
partners. If you run an
advertising agency that works
with a particular printing
company, for example, let your
newsletter subscribers know how
that company gives customers
superior quality. When you help
an ally, they’ll be more likely
to help you or mention your
company in their newsletter.
Source: www.fuelnet.com
- When your company
makes a mistake, do you offer
refunds or discounts?
Instead, consider offering
additional products or services
whose value equals or exceeds
the refund amount. For example,
a printer misses a deadline, and
instead of refunding $100 to the
customer, offers to print 20%
more of the order and give the
customer an extra color free
next time he comes in. The
concessions are worth more than
$100 to the customer even though
they won’t cost the printer $100
to perform them, plus the free
color encourages the customer to
return to the shop.
Source: www.businessbyphone.com
- Increase your odds
of getting a signed contract
by asking the “expected results”
question, suggests Steve
Slaunwhite, co-author of The
Wealthy Freelancer. Ask,
“What exactly do you need this
project to accomplish?” The more
you position your services
around the wanted results, the
more likely you are to get the
job — at the price you want. Be
sure to restate their answer
within your project proposal.
The great thing about this
tactic is that it uses the
client’s own thinking to
persuade them that the
investment is worthwhile.
Source: www.yudkin.com
- Reduce absenteeism
at your company this summer
— and save your employees a lot
of grief — by helping them
locate quality summer child-care
programs. For guidance, visit
www.nccic.org.
- Customize your
Facebook Page (fan
page) using the Static FBML app.
If you find Facebook’s format to
be too limiting, this
application allows you to create
a custom tab (landing page) for
your fans. Just search for
“Static FBML” in Facebook. Once
you find the app, click on “Add
to my page.” This app can be a
bit technical and requires you
to know HTML or FBML, so you may
want to ask a web developer for
help. For more information on
Static FBML, go to
http://bit.ly/btlFib.
Source: www.smallbiztrends.com
- Add some tunes to
create a more pleasant workplace
experience. Fifty-nine
percent of employees who listen
to music at work say they aren’t
likely to call in sick for work
compared with only 32% who don’t
listen to music at work,
according to Entertainment Media
Research. Most employees who
listen to music at work describe
their workplace as happy
compared with less than half of
those who don’t listen to music.
In addition, 81% of employees
said music in the workplace
creates a more enjoyable
experience. Before implementing
this idea, develop a policy for
personal music players. If you
play music over a sound system
so the entire staff can hear it,
vary the styles of music. In
addition, maintain a low volume
so you don’t distract workers.
Source:
www.workplacemagazine.com
- If you’re hiring new
employees, you are
probably receiving a flood of
resumes or applications — many
from unqualified applicants. To
avoid wasting your time sorting
through this deluge of
paperwork, pre-screen applicants
by asking them to answer
detailed and specific questions
that are relevant to the job.
Now you can quickly distinguish
between those who actually meet
the qualifications and those who
are applying to anything and
everything, hoping to find work.
Source:
thehiringsite.careerbuilder.com
- Don’t file for that
patent yet!
Successfully taking a product to
market requires research and the
ability to talk to people about
your invention. Inventors
reluctant to share their
invention with people they don’t
know will often rush out and
file a full-blown, utility
patent application. However, at
a fraction of the cost, a
provisional patent application
can be submitted. A provisional
patent is not actually a patent,
but it acts like a place holder.
In essence, you are laying claim
to the filing date of the
provisional patent application
if and when you elect to file
for a full utility patent up to
one year from the time you file
your provisional patent
application. This gives you the
legal right to write “patent
pending” on your prototype and
show it to whomever you wish.
Contact a patent attorney for
more information.
Source: www.entreprenuer.com
- If you are genuinely
interested in obtaining customer
feedback, train your
employees to ask, “What’s one
thing we could do better next
time?” Not: “How was your meal?
Did you enjoy….? Was everything
all right?” These are
close-ended questions and people
will typically answer, “Fine,”
or “Yes.” You need an
opened-ended question that
overcomes the customers’
inclinations to be polite — that
provides a higher quality of
feedback. Of course, be prepared
to act on that feedback.
Source: www.allbusiness.com
Business Intelligence Report
(ISSN 1091-9597) is published 12 times a
year by DBH Communications, Inc. PO Box
22337 Kansas City, MO 64113, email:
4info@bizintellreport.com.
Subscriptions are $89 per year.
The intent of this publication is to
provide business professionals with
informative and interesting articles and
news. These articles, and any opinions
expressed in them, are for general
information only and are not intended to
provide specific advice or
recommendations for any individual or
business. Appropriate legal, accounting,
financial or medical advice or other
expert assistance should always be
sought from a competent professional.
Copyright, 2010, DBH Communications,
Inc. All rights reserved in all
countries. Reproduction or use, without
written permission, of editorial or
graphic content in any manner is
prohibited.
This e-mail newsletter message is
brought to you by the Greater Richmond Chamber of
Commerce. If you would like to opt out
from receiving this newsletter, please
contact the chamber regarding your
request.
|